President Trump has reiterated his intention to eliminate federal taxes on Social Security benefits. He hopes Congress will endorse this move and send it to his desk for approval. During an address to Congress in early March, President Trump called for a law exempting Social Security benefits from taxation.
Eliminating these taxes would likely increase take-home income for many seniors, but it also presents significant challenges. The Social Security fund is financially strained, and taxes on Social Security benefits help to offset this shortfall.
Removing them could widen the gap, further destabilizing a program that millions of seniors rely on as their primary source of income. Without additional reforms—such as lifting the income cap on Social Security taxes—this policy change might exacerbate the program’s financial difficulties rather than resolve them. According to the Social Security Administration (SSA), about forty percent of Social Security beneficiaries pay taxes on their benefits.
However, the income levels under which taxation is determined were set in 1984 and have yet to be adjusted for inflation. As a result, many more beneficiaries are subject to tax because of these outdated thresholds. For single filers, tax is paid on up to 50% of benefits if annual income falls between $25,000 and $34,000 (or $77,231.60 and $105,034.98 when adjusted for inflation).
Taxes are paid on up to 85% of benefits if annual income exceeds $34,000 (or greater than $105,034.98 when adjusted for inflation). For couples who file jointly, taxes are paid on up to 50% of benefits if household income is between $32,000 and $44,000 (or $98,856.45 and $135,927.62 when adjusted for inflation). Taxes are paid on up to 85% of benefits if household income exceeds $44,000 (or greater than $135,927.62 when adjusted for inflation).
Some financial planners call these unadjusted thresholds a “stealth tax.” Jordan Gilberti, a senior lead planner and certified financial planner at Facet, remarked that many people know how Social Security benefits are taxed.
Trump’s plan for Social Security taxes
He mentions that people are often surprised when they learn about the process.
According to the US Census Bureau, the median household income for seniors was $50,290 in 2022. Many of these households might not pay taxes on their benefits if the thresholds were adjusted for inflation. There are two primary arguments against taxing Social Security benefits.
The first argument, which appeals to politicians like President Trump, is that seniors shouldn’t pay taxes on benefits they have already funded through payroll taxes during their working years. This argument is compelling, especially given that around 10% of seniors live in poverty. Taxing these benefits can be a significant burden for those slightly above the poverty line.
However, if tax thresholds were adjusted for inflation, most beneficiaries would not be taxed. Those who would still pay taxes on their benefits tend to be high-net-worth individuals who may not have contributed their fair share of Social Security taxes while in the workforce. One potential solution is lifting the income cap on Social Security taxes.
Only income up to $132,900 is subject to the Social Security tax. By lifting this cap, the federal government could secure Social Security’s long-term solvency while also expanding benefits. For example, this reform could fund a $1,300 benefit increase for seniors currently receiving less than $16,000 annually—a group that makes up nearly 30% of all beneficiaries.
President Trump’s plan to eliminate taxes on Social Security benefits aims to increase net incomes for some seniors. Still, it falls short of addressing the broader issue of Social Security’s long-term solvency. While it could provide immediate financial relief for some, without additional measures to secure the program’s funding, the proposal may further destabilize an already strained system. This reform championed by President Trump is a topic of significant debate, and its long-term impacts remain to be seen.
The conversation around Social Security benefits and their taxation continues to evolve, reflecting broader concerns about retirement security and economic stability for seniors.
Image Credits: Photo by Ramaz Bluashvili on Pexels
